skip to Main Content
Best Insurance Lead Companies: A Guide For Agents

Best Insurance Lead Companies: A Guide for Agents

Our TOP 2 Picks:

For fresh insurance leads: Sharpen Clicks

For aged insurance leads: Badass Insurance Leads

When it comes to finding the best insurance lead companies, there’s a lot of noise out there for your typical life insurance leads agent and broker. 

You’ve probably heard countless suggestions and read numerous reviews on lead vendors. 

But here’s an undeniable fact: Not all insurance lead generation companies are created equal.

To be successful in your insurance business, you need quality leads from reliable sources.

Otherwise, you risk wasting valuable time and resources chasing cold leads that won’t convert into customers.

In this post, we’ll introduce you to some of the best insurance lead companies that can help boost your sales performance and grow your agency.

We’ll also provide advice on assessing these suppliers so that you can make educated decisions for your enterprise.

Understanding What Makes Insurance Leads Companies Good or Bad

Let’s cut to the chase: not all leads are created equal. And neither are insurance lead companies. If you’re an insurance agent or broker wanting to expand your business, it’s important to understand what attributes to look for.

The Anatomy of a Good Insurance Lead Company

A top-notch insurance lead company doesn’t just sell leads; they provide high-quality, originally sourced leads that can help you acquire new customers and grow your business faster. They don’t just hand over a list of names – they offer guidance on building effective strategies around those resources.

EverQuote, for instance, not only provides top-notch quality leads but also assigns dedicated account managers as part of their core growth program. Talk about value.

Other companies, like ours, Badass Insurance Leads, offers a money back guarantee.

Differentiating Between Aggregators and Generators

In the world of insurance lead companies, there are two main players: aggregators and generators. Understanding the difference between them is key in choosing where to purchase your leads from.

  • Lead aggregators: These companies buy up large quantities of leads from other aggregators or directly from generators before selling them off again (think middlemen).
  • Lead generators: These companies source most or all of their own fresh-as-a-daisy leads through various marketing channels such as online advertising, direct mail campaigns, etc.

Your success with purchasing insurance leads isn’t set in stone – it’s something that should be revisited regularly based on how successful you become at converting these prospects into clients. A reputable provider will allow flexibility when it comes to adjusting the number of purchased contacts according to your evolving needs and successes. Remember this golden rule: always keep track and adjust accordingly.

You’ve done some homework now on understanding different types of providers out there along with identifying key factors while selecting one. The next step? Dive deeper into evaluating specific options like SmartFinancial, Datalot, QuoteWizard, among others which we’ll cover in our upcoming sections.

See also  The Ultimate Guide to Buying Aged Insurance Leads [2023]

Top 5 Insurance Lead Companies

Let’s dive into five of the best insurance lead companies out there.


SmartFinancial is like a ninja with a spreadsheet – stealthy yet effective at delivering high-quality auto and home insurance leads. Their real-time delivery system ensures fresh prospects right to your inbox.


Datalot is where technology meets human touch. With their unique call-verified leads approach, they ensure every prospect is pre-screened before it lands on your desk – saving you time and boosting conversion rates.


QuoteWizard is like your personal magician pulling quality leads out of their hat. Offering an array of lead types from health to renters’ insurance, they cater to diverse agent needs while maintaining stringent quality control measures for each lead.

Bonus Tip:

A quick chat with these providers can reveal if they offer any exclusive deals or discounts for bulk purchases – worth checking out.

Hometown Quotes

Hometown Quotes is like having a local guide in uncharted territory. They pride themselves on providing region-specific leads tailored to meet your agency’s specific requirements, ensuring higher chances for conversions. Plus, their dedicated account managers add that extra layer of personalized service.

Pro Tip:

Always check if these vendors have flexible cancellation policies – because let’s face it, no one likes being stuck in an unsatisfactory contract.


Partnering with top-notch providers like EverQuote ensures access to high-quality originally sourced leads along with guidance on building effective strategies around those resources which ultimately helps grow businesses faster.

  • EverQuote’s Core Growth Program: Offers not just robust lead generation but also includes dedicated account management support – making sure you get bang for your buck.
  • Accelerated Growth Program and Agency Business Consultant Services: If you have aggressive goals in mind (and why shouldn’t you?), ask about these services as well.

Key Questions to Ask Before Choosing an Insurance Lead Company

If you’re an insurance agent or broker looking to buy insurance leads, you may be wondering which company to choose. Fear not. Here’s a roadmap to help you make that crucial decision.

Are you a lead aggregator or generator?

First things first: figure out whether the company is a lead aggregator or generator. A lead aggregator buys leads from other aggregators or generators, while a lead generator sources all their own leads. It’s important to know what you’re buying into.

Do you resell or recycle your leads?

The next stop on our journey is recycling, and no, we aren’t talking about plastic bottles here. Some companies recycle old leads information – make sure yours doesn’t, unless it’s part of your strategy for aged insurance leads.

What kind of incentives are there?

Moving right along, let’s talk incentives. Companies use various methods to gather lead info; some might offer free quotes while others may promise exclusive deals. Make sure their approach aligns with your business values and customer expectations.

Evaluating Their Level of Customer Service

Last but definitely not least:

Your potential partner should have stellar customer service – remember, this isn’t just about purchasing lists of names, it’s about building relationships that will help grow your business faster.

Evaluating Potential Growth with an Insurance Lead Company

Now that we’ve covered the key questions to ask, let’s shift gears to evaluating potential growth.

Variety of Service Packages Offered by the Vendor

  1. Finding the perfect fit: Look at the variety of packages offered by vendors – can they cater to both small-scale needs as well as large volume requirements?
See also  Life Insurance Sales: Challenges, Tips, and Career Prospects

Potential for Scaling as per Business Growth & Flexibility in Account Management

  1. Aiming higher: Can these providers scale up services according to your agency’s growth trajectory? Do they allow flexibility in managing accounts so you can revisit purchased quantities based on success rates?
Dedicated Account Manager and Cancellation Policies
  1. The finer details: Does the vendor provide dedicated account management support? What are their cancellation policies like? Considering these nuances could be pivotal in forming lasting associations.

By asking these key questions and evaluating potential growth, you’ll be well on your way to choosing the best insurance lead company for your needs.

When it comes to choosing an insurance lead generator, you’re not just buying leads. You’re investing in the potential growth of your agency.

Flexibility and Scalability Options for Purchasing Leads

You need a partner that can scale with you as your business grows. That means flexibility in purchasing options and scalability for future expansion.

Ask about their packages: Can they handle small orders for startups? What about bulk orders for established agencies?

If they have rigid structures or lack scalability, it might be time to bounce like a bad check.

Variety of Service Packages Offered by the Vendor

Diversity is key here – both in terms of services offered and pricing models. Do they offer real-time leads, aged leads, exclusive or shared ones?

The more variety on offer, the better chances you have at finding something that fits your unique needs like Cinderella’s glass slipper.

Account Management and Cancellation Policies

A good vendor will provide dedicated account management support – someone who knows your name (and how to pronounce it), understands your goals and helps optimize strategies.

This, my friends, can make all the difference between feeling lost at sea or cruising smoothly towards success island.

The Core Growth Program: Your Dedicated Account Manager

  • A dedicated account manager should be part of any core growth program provided by an insurance lead company.
  • This person would work closely with you to understand specific needs & challenges related to generating quality insurance leads.
  • They’ll also guide on best practices around managing these resources effectively.

If cancellation policies are hidden behind jargon-filled walls taller than Game of Thrones’ Wall…run. It’s essential that the conditions of what transpires if things don’t go as planned are made clear.

Note: As an agent looking for aggressive growth opportunities, inquire about accelerated growth programs and availability of agency business consultants while comparing vendors.

Remember folks; evaluating potential growth isn’t just about numbers but also understanding how well a vendor aligns with your long-term vision & provides value beyond mere transactions.

So put on those detective glasses and start asking these questions today.


Looking for the best insurance lead companies can be tough, but asking the right questions and evaluating growth opportunities can help you make an informed decision.

After researching various options, we’ve identified the top five insurance lead companies: SmartFinancial, Datalot, QuoteWizard, Hometown Quotes, and EverQuote.

Each of these providers offers unique features and benefits that cater to different business needs, so you can find the perfect fit for your agency.

If you’re looking for a reliable partner to help grow your business with quality leads, consider EverQuote, which provides flexible purchasing options and excellent customer service.

Don’t just take our word for it, though. Check out these credible sources to see what others are saying about the best insurance lead companies:

With the right partner, you can take your business to the next level and achieve your goals.

Dustin DeTorres

Dustin DeTorres is the Co-Founder of Badass Insurance Leads. For over a decade, he's helped insurance agents across the USA close deals by generating leads for their businesses.